XXHighEnd - The Ultra HighEnd Audio Player
November 23, 2024, 11:50:58 am *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: August 6, 2017 : Phasure Webshop open ! Go to the Shop
Search current board structure only !!  
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1] 2  All
  Print  
Author Topic: An interesting article about HiRes recordings  (Read 21260 times)
0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.
Calibrator
Audio Enthusiast
**
Offline Offline

Posts: 556

Certified tweakaholic


View Profile
« on: March 12, 2012, 07:12:49 am »

I was forwarded a link to an interesting article a few days back regarding the virtues (or not) of high resolution recording, that I thought most here might enjoy reading.

http://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html

Now, I happen to agree with most of the ideas put forward, but I'm sure there will be a few here in disagreement  Grin

Enjoy the read .. I did!

Cheers,

Russ
Logged

(Sep 26th 2012) (0.9z-7-4 )
Parameters (0.9z-7-4) ->Coming soon...
Parameters (0.9z-6-1) ->Same as for 0.9z-6
Parameters (0.9z-6) ->http://members.iinet.net.au/~calibrator/XXHE/XXHE_parms_(0.9z-6).jpg
Hardware: Asus P5Q, H2O cooled 3.6GHz C2D, 8GB ram, W7 Ult X64 (NO SP1), O/S plus Galleries on 2x(OCZ 60GB Vertex2) -> ESI Juli@ (v0.978 drivers @ 48 samples) -> coax SPDIF -> Integra DHC-9.9 -> Hafler XL600 -> SGR Audio S-series Octagons -> aural organs -> nucleus accumbens sounds good !

====================
Turntables .. how quaint bored
bambadoo
Audio Loudspeaker
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 10


View Profile Email
« Reply #1 on: March 12, 2012, 07:36:00 am »

Yes it is interesting.
Not much mumbo jumbo in that article.

Still I have a feeling that age is quite important regarding these issues.

Lots of people really enjoy hirez music and hirez dacs. Still just as many prefer 16bit/18bit dacs (tda1541, ad1865 etc..)
Strange isn't it?
Logged
gsbrva
Audio Loudspeaker
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 31


View Profile Email
« Reply #2 on: March 12, 2012, 03:44:48 pm »

Interesting article.  The one area that really lost me was the argument about bandwidth limiting.  I'd rather not make the format a crutch for bad amplifier design.
Logged

Digital playback system = XXhighend 0.9z-6-1c KS adaptive (engine 4), Dev Buffer 2048, straight contiguous > Windows 8 64 bit preview, Quad core Q6600 Intel 2.4 ghz, 6gig memory > P965/ICH8 chipset w/usb PCIe NEC USB3 card > Hiface Evo > I2S > NOS TDA1545A/1387 w/Crystek CCHD-957 clock chip backfeed to Evo ext clock in > dac current output into low Z transformer input Altec A256C beam power amplifiers> Quad ESL63 pro
Scroobius
Audio Addict
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 1170


View Profile
« Reply #3 on: March 12, 2012, 10:49:02 pm »

Hi Calibrator - a very good read thanks for posting. It certainly supports what I hear with my system - some of the very best recordings I have were recorded in the 50/60's and are recorded at 16/44.

Although I have some exceptional modern recordings they tend to be produced by specialist recording engineers and are mostly 16/44. I have some superb 24/96 recordings also but not (I think) because they are 24/96 more because the recording engineer was superb.

Paul

Logged

621 Xeon 6120 LPS PC  -> Xeon Scalable 16/32 core with Hyperthreading On (all cores active) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1/ Q1Factor = 10 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 15ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.69  (max 140.19) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Off / WallPaper Off/ OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = 35 / Nervous Rate = 10 / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 0 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / *Arc Prediction Filtering (16x)* / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^2*A:B-W-Y-R, B:B-W-R* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> *Blaxius^2 A:B-R, B:B-R* Interlink -> Orelino Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
pedal
Audio Enthusiast
**
Offline Offline

Posts: 402

XXHighEnd is THE best buy in Hi-Fi. Thank U Peter!


View Profile
« Reply #4 on: March 13, 2012, 01:20:40 am »

What a stupid blog post. It reminds my about those who state that "there are no audible differences between cables, because there are no measurable differences to speak of". Or who claims that "there cannot be differences between software players or computers if both are bit-perfect, etc etc bla bla"

For this purpose, ABX sucks. Rapid repetions in an ABX test is doomed to end in a nul result. ABX is close to useless for finetasting in sound. You have to listen for longer periode to various music without stress.

He also advocates oversampling. The NOS1 DAC is all about avoiding oversampling.

Several recording engineers has stated many times that when recording from the same source, higher bit/sampling (than redbook) sounds better.

Even ripping your LPs sounds better in 24/96 than 16/44.

Unfortunately articles like this creates more confusion.

Of course, the difference is not that big, and some CDs sound spectacular too. And some old recordings sound bad whatever format. But that doesnt change the fact that a modern well recorded album sounds better in hi-rez.
-The sound is more "fluent", microdynamics are more "real" and there are more nuances even in the bass. It is the tiny aspects of sound reproduction which improves.

(Sorry for faulty spelling. I wrote it on my phone sitting on the loo. A fitting tribute to the blog post reference).
Logged

Hardware: Stealth Mach III > Lush^2 > 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3  > active preamp > 3-way active XO > amps > ribbon/dynamic true line source speakers.

Settings all settings as recommended by Peter by October 2019.
PeterSt
Administrator
High Grade Audiophile
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 16854



View Profile Email
« Reply #5 on: March 13, 2012, 09:08:39 am »

Quote
Sorry for faulty spelling. I wrote it on my phone sitting on the loo

yahoo rofl
Logged

For the Stealth III LPS PC :
W10-14393.0 - July 17, 2021 (2.11)
XXHighEnd Mach III Stealth LPS PC -> Xeon Scalable 14/28 core with Hyperthreading On (set to 14/28 cores in BIOS and set to 10/20 cores via Boot Menu) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/0/0/*1*/ Q1Factor = *4* / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = *10ms* / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = *10.13*  (max 10.13) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *62* / Nervous Rate = *1* / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / Custom Filtering *Low* (16x) / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^3
A: W-Y-R-G, B: *W-G* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> Blaxius*^2.5* A:B-G, B:B-G Interlink -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers. ET^2 Ethernet from Mach III to Music Server PC (RDC Control).
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere (also from the PC).

For a general PC :
W10-10586.0 - May 2016 (2.05+)
*XXHighEnd PC -> I7 3930k with Hyperthreading On (12 cores)* @~500MHz, 16GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 10586.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1 / Q1Factor = 1 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 1ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.10  (max 60) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / All Services Off / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD On / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *43* / Nervous Rate = 1 / Cool when Idle = 1 / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = *Optimal* / Time Stability = *Stable* / Custom Filter *Low* 705600 / -> USB3 *from MoBo* -> Clairixa USB 15cm -> Intona Isolator -> Clairixa USB 1m80 -> 24/768 Phasure NOS1a 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (4ms) -> Blaxius BNC interlink *-> B'ASS Current Amplifier /w Level4 -> Blaxius Interlink* -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere.

Global Moderator
bambadoo
Audio Loudspeaker
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 10


View Profile Email
« Reply #6 on: March 13, 2012, 09:23:07 am »

pedal - feel free to elaborate further.

When we know about all the "false" marketing tricks from some resellers of HD music - and all they do is to introduce "noise" in one form or another - how can this be good?

If your ears tell you otherwise it is a good thing for you.
I have analyzed some HD material (using izotope RX, audiocity etc.). I can tell you, not all is good.
I think it is a very good article. Maybe everything is not 100% correct but it makes you think doesn't it?



Logged
PeterSt
Administrator
High Grade Audiophile
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 16854



View Profile Email
« Reply #7 on: March 13, 2012, 09:23:26 am »

Well, what the article did - or merely postings about it elsewhere - is that I FINALLY seem to have found a reason why the best natively recorded HiRes can sound worse than the to 16/44.1 decimated same recording.

So as we all know, I keep on being persistent that HiRes doesn't sound better at all, and this with the NOS1 behaving electrically 100% the same as when it's fed with Redbook.
That this is subjective to some extend (like pedal being out of line with this (or me !) is clear too of course, but at least it is me trying to squeeze the best out of Redbook. Ehm, you all do of course, but I can use different means (and you can only use mine for it scratching).

It is too early perhaps, but I have now found a sheer technical reason how native HiRes can sound worse.
But, it needs the NOS1 and Arc Prediction Upsampling to be in that technical realm. I mean, with any normal DAC this difference can hardly be there (or actually not at all), which should imply that on that normal DAC HiRes sound better than Redbook.
That now Redbook sounds relatively miserable is something else ...

Btw, to some extend, just using Arc Prediction with a normal DAC will also let HiRes *not* sound better. But here YMMV very much, and I myself can't even judge it (lacking such a DAC).

Eh, more later ?
Logged

For the Stealth III LPS PC :
W10-14393.0 - July 17, 2021 (2.11)
XXHighEnd Mach III Stealth LPS PC -> Xeon Scalable 14/28 core with Hyperthreading On (set to 14/28 cores in BIOS and set to 10/20 cores via Boot Menu) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/0/0/*1*/ Q1Factor = *4* / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = *10ms* / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = *10.13*  (max 10.13) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *62* / Nervous Rate = *1* / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / Custom Filtering *Low* (16x) / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^3
A: W-Y-R-G, B: *W-G* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> Blaxius*^2.5* A:B-G, B:B-G Interlink -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers. ET^2 Ethernet from Mach III to Music Server PC (RDC Control).
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere (also from the PC).

For a general PC :
W10-10586.0 - May 2016 (2.05+)
*XXHighEnd PC -> I7 3930k with Hyperthreading On (12 cores)* @~500MHz, 16GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 10586.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1 / Q1Factor = 1 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 1ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.10  (max 60) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / All Services Off / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD On / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *43* / Nervous Rate = 1 / Cool when Idle = 1 / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = *Optimal* / Time Stability = *Stable* / Custom Filter *Low* 705600 / -> USB3 *from MoBo* -> Clairixa USB 15cm -> Intona Isolator -> Clairixa USB 1m80 -> 24/768 Phasure NOS1a 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (4ms) -> Blaxius BNC interlink *-> B'ASS Current Amplifier /w Level4 -> Blaxius Interlink* -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere.

Global Moderator
PeterSt
Administrator
High Grade Audiophile
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 16854



View Profile Email
« Reply #8 on: March 13, 2012, 09:27:27 am »

Quote
I think it is a very good article. Maybe everything is not 100% correct but it makes you think doesn't it?

I think so too. And this is to such a degree that I am not much able to "attack" it right from that origine.
That I can write pages full of it is another matter.

The point is : there is much more going on, and the article is not about that. So it is about the in-parallel other things going on which makes the article "wrong". But within itself I see it as quite consistent ...

Peter
Logged

For the Stealth III LPS PC :
W10-14393.0 - July 17, 2021 (2.11)
XXHighEnd Mach III Stealth LPS PC -> Xeon Scalable 14/28 core with Hyperthreading On (set to 14/28 cores in BIOS and set to 10/20 cores via Boot Menu) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/0/0/*1*/ Q1Factor = *4* / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = *10ms* / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = *10.13*  (max 10.13) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *62* / Nervous Rate = *1* / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / Custom Filtering *Low* (16x) / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^3
A: W-Y-R-G, B: *W-G* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> Blaxius*^2.5* A:B-G, B:B-G Interlink -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers. ET^2 Ethernet from Mach III to Music Server PC (RDC Control).
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere (also from the PC).

For a general PC :
W10-10586.0 - May 2016 (2.05+)
*XXHighEnd PC -> I7 3930k with Hyperthreading On (12 cores)* @~500MHz, 16GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 10586.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1 / Q1Factor = 1 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 1ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.10  (max 60) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / All Services Off / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD On / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *43* / Nervous Rate = 1 / Cool when Idle = 1 / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = *Optimal* / Time Stability = *Stable* / Custom Filter *Low* 705600 / -> USB3 *from MoBo* -> Clairixa USB 15cm -> Intona Isolator -> Clairixa USB 1m80 -> 24/768 Phasure NOS1a 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (4ms) -> Blaxius BNC interlink *-> B'ASS Current Amplifier /w Level4 -> Blaxius Interlink* -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere.

Global Moderator
Scroobius
Audio Addict
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 1170


View Profile
« Reply #9 on: March 13, 2012, 09:31:01 am »

Quote
NOS1 DAC is all about avoiding oversampling

Is it? Well yes as Peter rightly avoids using the word "oversampling" because of its interpolation connotations. But of course NOS1 does increase the input data stream to one with a much higher sample rate and for exactly the same reasons that oversampling was intended to do. Unless of course any of us listen at 44.1 which I certainly don't.

Quote
Of course, the difference is not that big

Certainly agree with that but I would add "if at all". And then I would ask why are my very best sounding recordings 16/44?


Logged

621 Xeon 6120 LPS PC  -> Xeon Scalable 16/32 core with Hyperthreading On (all cores active) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1/ Q1Factor = 10 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 15ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.69  (max 140.19) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Off / WallPaper Off/ OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = 35 / Nervous Rate = 10 / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 0 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / *Arc Prediction Filtering (16x)* / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^2*A:B-W-Y-R, B:B-W-R* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> *Blaxius^2 A:B-R, B:B-R* Interlink -> Orelino Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
pedal
Audio Enthusiast
**
Offline Offline

Posts: 402

XXHighEnd is THE best buy in Hi-Fi. Thank U Peter!


View Profile
« Reply #10 on: March 13, 2012, 12:36:58 pm »

With the advantage of a qwert keyboard and after a good night sleep, I can deepen my view on this so called “article”:

I found 2 interesting parts:

1. The tech talk about IM distortion. Which is an audible factor for owners of faulty constructed amplifiers. –Stable amplifiers with low distortion and bandwidth up to, and beyond 100kHz is easily achievable in regular AB transistor amplifiers these days, if the designer wants to. The “faulty” ones in this regard are to be found among tube amplifiers and class D amplifiers. Owners of such should aware, ha-ha. But pls don’t deny high resolution music formats just because you have a low tech amplifier…  Tongue

2. The physical mechanics of our ear and the reference to the Fletcher and Munson curve is also interesting read.

------------

The rest of the blog post by "Monty" I find to be malicious and highly biased propaganda.

Mr Monty happens to be Christopher Montgomery, who has spend the last 15 years developing and advocating Vorbis. A lossy music compression format competing in the marked with such as MP3 and Apples AAC. In fact, the blog post is a direct attack on Apple’s iTunes. So much for his credibility.

Monty is a low-rez guy. If you read carefully all his blog post, and the sources he lists, they are mainly from the “objectivist” camp living in a simplified world.
-They don’t trust individual listening experiences. Subjective listening only becomes objective when run through a ABX process with multiple repetitions of the same piece of music.
With this kind of mentality and ABX method, they find no difference between 24/96 and 16/44. Also there are numerous ABX tests showing no difference between lossy MP3 and CD. So there you go: Lossy MP3 is as good as 24/96! Say no more.

Mr Monty is a malicious propagandist because he omits known facts, which I am sure he knows very well. This man has spent 10 years programming and writing algorithms for his lossy music format. For sure he knows that our hearing is not only a physical matter (the outer mechanical part of our ear). Just as important is the psychoacoustic part. How our brain analyzes and percepts. In this field the scientists are only scratching the surface. There is so much going on in our brain, processing sounds, etc.

His analogy to the eye is quite misguiding and irrelevant. Especially when it comes to performing comparisons. Comparing A and B with sight is easy, because you can watch (let’s say) 2 photographs side by side, in real time.
But you cannot compare 2 pieces of music simultainsly. Both A and B must be heard one at a time and “stored” in your memory. Then compared from memory. It’s a completely different story, which Mr Monty elegantly avoids to mention.

Also he simplifies the Nyquist–Shannon sampling theorem. Mainly because increased bit depth is not only a matter of wider dynamic range, but also a more accurate calculating of the tiny amplitudes. Shortly put, for those into fishing with nets: More bits create a bigger net, but also a net with smaller masks. It captures more fish (bigger net) but also smaller fish (smaller masks). 

And what about square waves? Many music instruments are full of both DC- and square wave signals. That’s why we hear them as “real”. And that is a large reason why we hear them as “reproduces” on records. Because neither the format nor the hardware has enough bandwidth. –This is also a gross omission in Mr Montys piece of propaganda.     

There are numerous statements from well respected music engineers that higher sampling rates and bit depths improves the sound quality. And this is of course when they record and compare from the same source. 16/44 is not the threshold of our hearing, as Mr Monty falsely advocates. To paraphrase Mr Churchill I would say Red Book is not the end, but merely the begging of our sonic journey!

I have done quite some research in this matter. If anybody is interested I can post some links from recording engineers, discussing the limitations of 16/44.

-------------------

Much of the first generation of hi-rez music was made shortly after year 2000, when DVD-A was launched. Most of the effort went into the formats 5.1 surround sound virtues. They dusted of the mastertapes of the old top selling albums and made some very good multichannel releases. But they didn’t pay same attention to the stereo versions on the same disk. Some of these are cr*ppy sounding with heavy compression, which at that time had developed into ia decease among mastering engineers. Censored !

I guess some hi-fi enthusiasts have developed skepticism towards hi-rez, due to bad experience from such 1st. generation releases. But you cannot judge a technical format, based on wrongly usage. That is quite obvious. Let’s be patient, and let the format develop.

I have several good hi-rez recordings and they sound wonderful. More alive and more “natural” than Red book which in comparison has a slight “artificial” signature. A kind of subtle “dryness”, even if the recording is very soave, soaked in a glorious “tubey” sound signature.  (It’s hard to explain, sorry).

PS: My amplifiers have flat response from 0 to almost 1MHz, with near immeasurable distortion. In fact my playback chain is entirely DC-coupled, from NOS1 DAC to my loudspeakers, including the DC-coupled active crossovers. 
Logged

Hardware: Stealth Mach III > Lush^2 > 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3  > active preamp > 3-way active XO > amps > ribbon/dynamic true line source speakers.

Settings all settings as recommended by Peter by October 2019.
PeterSt
Administrator
High Grade Audiophile
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 16854



View Profile Email
« Reply #11 on: March 13, 2012, 02:12:25 pm »

Okay, at bringing forward those thoughts about the article, I can't go much against that.
I must admit that I stopped reading when the MP3 stuff started.

Peter
Logged

For the Stealth III LPS PC :
W10-14393.0 - July 17, 2021 (2.11)
XXHighEnd Mach III Stealth LPS PC -> Xeon Scalable 14/28 core with Hyperthreading On (set to 14/28 cores in BIOS and set to 10/20 cores via Boot Menu) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/0/0/*1*/ Q1Factor = *4* / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = *10ms* / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = *10.13*  (max 10.13) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *62* / Nervous Rate = *1* / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / Custom Filtering *Low* (16x) / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^3
A: W-Y-R-G, B: *W-G* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> Blaxius*^2.5* A:B-G, B:B-G Interlink -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers. ET^2 Ethernet from Mach III to Music Server PC (RDC Control).
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere (also from the PC).

For a general PC :
W10-10586.0 - May 2016 (2.05+)
*XXHighEnd PC -> I7 3930k with Hyperthreading On (12 cores)* @~500MHz, 16GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 10586.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1 / Q1Factor = 1 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 1ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.10  (max 60) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / All Services Off / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD On / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *43* / Nervous Rate = 1 / Cool when Idle = 1 / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = *Optimal* / Time Stability = *Stable* / Custom Filter *Low* 705600 / -> USB3 *from MoBo* -> Clairixa USB 15cm -> Intona Isolator -> Clairixa USB 1m80 -> 24/768 Phasure NOS1a 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (4ms) -> Blaxius BNC interlink *-> B'ASS Current Amplifier /w Level4 -> Blaxius Interlink* -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere.

Global Moderator
PeterSt
Administrator
High Grade Audiophile
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 16854



View Profile Email
« Reply #12 on: March 14, 2012, 11:10:11 am »

Quote
Monty is a low-rez guy. If you read carefully all his blog post, and the sources he lists, they are mainly from the “objectivist” camp living in a simplified world.

I think we must be careful with accusations which may seem to allow to spring from logic, but where we still can't guarantee it is so.

Let's take one example : PeterSt. What does he do ? explicitly advocate 16/44.1. Okay, not because it "is so", but because there is a good reason to make it that. This, against that handful of Hires, which in the mean time PeterSt judges as s*cking all over. He really does you know.

So you see ? this is just an example, which hopefully (!!!) proves that we must be careful.

Btw, some months back I proposed MP3 as an explicit filtering means. Not that it worked out, but at least I had some theories about it.
This, in the context of how bad *I* can find that article.
But honestly, I have no judgement. It is too well written to go against it right away. Remember, in my view ...

Peter
Logged

For the Stealth III LPS PC :
W10-14393.0 - July 17, 2021 (2.11)
XXHighEnd Mach III Stealth LPS PC -> Xeon Scalable 14/28 core with Hyperthreading On (set to 14/28 cores in BIOS and set to 10/20 cores via Boot Menu) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/0/0/*1*/ Q1Factor = *4* / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = *10ms* / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = *10.13*  (max 10.13) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *62* / Nervous Rate = *1* / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / Custom Filtering *Low* (16x) / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^3
A: W-Y-R-G, B: *W-G* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> Blaxius*^2.5* A:B-G, B:B-G Interlink -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers. ET^2 Ethernet from Mach III to Music Server PC (RDC Control).
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere (also from the PC).

For a general PC :
W10-10586.0 - May 2016 (2.05+)
*XXHighEnd PC -> I7 3930k with Hyperthreading On (12 cores)* @~500MHz, 16GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 10586.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1 / Q1Factor = 1 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 1ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.10  (max 60) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / All Services Off / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD On / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *43* / Nervous Rate = 1 / Cool when Idle = 1 / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = *Optimal* / Time Stability = *Stable* / Custom Filter *Low* 705600 / -> USB3 *from MoBo* -> Clairixa USB 15cm -> Intona Isolator -> Clairixa USB 1m80 -> 24/768 Phasure NOS1a 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (4ms) -> Blaxius BNC interlink *-> B'ASS Current Amplifier /w Level4 -> Blaxius Interlink* -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere.

Global Moderator
pedal
Audio Enthusiast
**
Offline Offline

Posts: 402

XXHighEnd is THE best buy in Hi-Fi. Thank U Peter!


View Profile
« Reply #13 on: March 14, 2012, 12:37:07 pm »

Relax, Peter - your work cannot be compared with Monty’s work. You are aiming for the sky; he is aiming for the ground. With XXHE/NOS1 DAC you are trying to create the best possible sound quality in the world for the relatively few connoisseurs of high end. Mr Monty has created and advocates Vorbis, a lossy format for low-rez streaming audio in the mass marked.

The arguments in Mr Montys blog post circles around “how bad can things be done without audible degrading”. He is advocating mediocrity. You are pushing for perfection.

Basically all his blog post is a contradiction to your work. Here are some examples:
Red Book CD is good enough as it is today, applied with standard oversampling technology.
Music signals below 20 and above 20k has no relevance for people.
Sound differences don’t exist unless they are proven in ABX.
ABX proves that people doesn’t discern between CD and hi-rez.
ABX proves that people doesn’t discern between MP3 and CD.
Etc, etc

-------------

I think Mr Monty wrote his blog piece badly on purpose. Applying a very black/white perspective he has managed to provoke the high end community. His article is linked everywhere and made a big impact. He is probably having a good laugh now.

I dislike people who are pissing on my passion for highest fidelity sound reproduction. That’s why I wrote my previous post, pointing out Mr Montys malicious propaganda.
Logged

Hardware: Stealth Mach III > Lush^2 > 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3  > active preamp > 3-way active XO > amps > ribbon/dynamic true line source speakers.

Settings all settings as recommended by Peter by October 2019.
PeterSt
Administrator
High Grade Audiophile
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 16854



View Profile Email
« Reply #14 on: March 14, 2012, 01:26:14 pm »

Hey pedal,

Again, when you put it forward like that, I can only agree.
Still I think I "behave" similar.

... And as you know by know the whole article can be p*ssed on from all imagineable directions. Also by me.
But it is a complete indirect excercise and the reasoning about it is always for ... the better. Well, hopefully.

As you have seen I am now in the direction of "almost being able" to prove why Hires isn't better after all. It may fail, especially with you around as the exception of someone who really finds that Hires *is* the better sounding. So, including all like a good resolving system, XXHighEnd and a NOS1.
This should make me wonder, right ?

But what so stupidly remains is that all so much depends on the contents of that Hires itself. You know too that you judged something like good, while I did not plus some graphs should prove my right.
But merely, it is not about proving one's right. It is about IMproving, and for me it intrigues that Hires should do that while for me it does not at all. Or not enough.

The lucky thing is that Redbook can be so good.
I personally think this is way more important than trying to get Hires right. It isn't there anyway, so to speak.

In any event ... respectfully ...  Happy
Peter
Logged

For the Stealth III LPS PC :
W10-14393.0 - July 17, 2021 (2.11)
XXHighEnd Mach III Stealth LPS PC -> Xeon Scalable 14/28 core with Hyperthreading On (set to 14/28 cores in BIOS and set to 10/20 cores via Boot Menu) @~660MHz, 48GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 14393.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/0/0/*1*/ Q1Factor = *4* / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = *10ms* / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = *10.13*  (max 10.13) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / Stop Desktop, Remaining, WASAPI and W10 services / Use Remote Desktop / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD Off (!) / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *62* / Nervous Rate = *1* / Cool when Idle = n.a / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = Optimal / Time Stability = Stable / Custom Filtering *Low* (16x) / Always Clear Proxy before Playback = On -> USB3 from MoBo -> Lush^3
A: W-Y-R-G, B: *W-G* USB 1m00 -> Phisolator 24/768 Phasure NOS1a/G3 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (16ms) -> B'ASS Current Amplifier -> Blaxius*^2.5* A:B-G, B:B-G Interlink -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers. ET^2 Ethernet from Mach III to Music Server PC (RDC Control).
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere (also from the PC).

For a general PC :
W10-10586.0 - May 2016 (2.05+)
*XXHighEnd PC -> I7 3930k with Hyperthreading On (12 cores)* @~500MHz, 16GB, Windows 10 Pro 64 bit build 10586.0 from RAM, music on LAN / Engine#4 Adaptive Mode / Q1/-/3/4/5 = 14/-/1/1/1 / Q1Factor = 1 / Dev.Buffer = 4096 / ClockRes = 1ms / Memory = Straight Contiguous / Include Garbage Collect / SFS = 0.10  (max 60) / not Invert / Phase Alignment Off / Playerprio = Low / ThreadPrio = Realtime / Scheme = Core 3-5 / Not Switch Processors during Playback = Off/ Playback Drive none (see OS from RAM) / UnAttended (Just Start) / Always Copy to XX Drive (see OS from RAM) / All Services Off / Keep LAN - Not Persist / WallPaper On / OSD On / Running Time Off / Minimize OS / XTweaks : Balanced Load = *43* / Nervous Rate = 1 / Cool when Idle = 1 / Provide Stable Power = 1 / Utilize Cores always = 1 / Time Performance Index = *Optimal* / Time Stability = *Stable* / Custom Filter *Low* 705600 / -> USB3 *from MoBo* -> Clairixa USB 15cm -> Intona Isolator -> Clairixa USB 1m80 -> 24/768 Phasure NOS1a 75B (BNC Out) async USB DAC, Driver v1.0.4b (4ms) -> Blaxius BNC interlink *-> B'ASS Current Amplifier /w Level4 -> Blaxius Interlink* -> Orelo MKII Active Open Baffle Horn Speakers.
Removed Switching Supplies from everywhere.

Global Moderator
Pages: [1] 2  All
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1 RC2 | SMF © 2001-2005, Lewis Media Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.108 seconds with 20 queries.