Title: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 04, 2009, 08:31:26 pm hello P
have version 0,9x-7 with q 4/17/17/0/0 engine 3 no core appoint Player prio low Thread prio realtime attended taking signal from asus p5k-e motherboard of musicserver which has its own dedicated spdif hd audio rca output connected to spdif input of Buffalo 9008.plays just fine on redbook wav files but refuses to play hi rez files bought from us message as follows when hitting play: INVALIDARG 2/24/96000/384000/6 device cannot play enigine 3 did not start within the expected time what do I do wrong? best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on June 04, 2009, 10:38:17 pm Hmm Leif ...
That 384000 is wrong. I can't think of anything else than that this is my fault, but then why don't I have the problem myself ?? Is your DAC set at 24/192000 (and the "Needs 32 bits" ticked) ? If so, I don't have a better idea than to send me such a file please ... Just in case, please show the results of the DAC Test as well (not the Shared option). Kind regards, Peter Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 04, 2009, 11:14:29 pm yes the dac is set 24bit/192khZ and 32 bit
canīt make the test work how do I do? best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: AUDIODIDAKT on June 04, 2009, 11:20:01 pm I think peter means this test
Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 04, 2009, 11:22:21 pm yes I know but I cannot make it start and show result
best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: JohanZ on June 05, 2009, 12:07:25 am Quote but I cannot make it start and show result Select an audiotrackSelect DAC test keep it in attended mode select play button XX wil do the test i am not sure where you find the results. on the screen i think..... Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on June 05, 2009, 07:55:26 am Johan, thanks, and yes, on the screen (in a notepad document).
But Leif, the file to (dummy) play must be a normal 16/44.1 file ! If you can't get it to work never mind; when I have the example file I can pick it up from there. Peter Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 05, 2009, 09:50:20 am hello
now I am at work but this is how it is right now: I performed the test and it says only up to redbook std ? I take signal from ASUS P5K-E mainboard spdif output which says soundmax hd audio in sound devices working properly and it does on redbook files(sounds ok on my workshop rig) into spdif input on Buffalo 9008 24/192 dac a funny thing is also that the lock led on the Buffalo board goes out when I perform the xx dac test? weird is there any more settings to be done on the pc? BIOS says hd audio enabled best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 05, 2009, 10:35:59 am I came to think of one setting under sound devices:
properties: 3 tests are presented on dts/dolby or wma and 3 test on samplefreq 44 / 96 / 192 what to check and what NOT to check? best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on June 05, 2009, 04:55:29 pm Quote a funny thing is also that the lock led on the Buffalo board goes out when I perform the xx dac test? Pwew, that looks a kind of "dangerous" (to the sense of : can it be the DAC maybe ? -> my Buffalo just works). But I really think it is just my fault (but how ?). Quote what to check and what NOT to check? Those do nothing for Exclusive Mode (which is what we are using). You can't provide me such a file ? Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 05, 2009, 04:58:36 pm such a file what?
best Leif "not home until 19:00) Christensen Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on June 05, 2009, 05:09:53 pm ehh, such a one which doesn't play ?
Of course I'm implying that it is about the file(s) itself, but I wouldn't know what other. Again, the data you showed is wrong, but it is an indirect calculation I do from data in the file. So, I do something wrong, but I need the file to know/test what. That is, here 24/96 just work. Example : it could be 16/96 files ... (was it a special offer ? hahaha) Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 05, 2009, 05:19:39 pm It plays at PEDALS place on the Eximus player
will send when home best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 05, 2009, 09:27:59 pm this is what the dac test shows
Start Audio Device Analysis Exclusive Mode support Digital utdataenhet (SPDIF) (2- High Definition Audio-enhet) Not supported : 2|16|44100|176400|4 Not supported : 2|24|44100|264600|6 Not supported : 2|32|44100|352800|8 Supported : 2|16|48000|192000|4 Not supported : 2|24|48000|288000|6 Not supported : 2|32|48000|384000|8 Supported : 2|16|88200|352800|4 Not supported : 2|24|88200|529200|6 Not supported : 2|32|88200|705600|8 Supported : 2|16|96000|384000|4 Not supported : 2|24|96000|576000|6 Not supported : 2|32|96000|768000|8 Supported : 2|16|176400|705600|4 Not supported : 2|24|176400|1058400|6 Not supported : 2|32|176400|1411200|8 Supported : 2|16|192000|768000|4 Not supported : 2|24|192000|1152000|6 Not supported : 2|32|192000|1536000|8 Not supported : 2|16|352800|1411200|4 Not supported : 2|24|352800|2116800|6 Not supported : 2|32|352800|2822400|8 Not supported : 2|16|384000|1536000|4 Not supported : 2|24|384000|2304000|6 Not supported : 2|32|384000|3072000|8 with dac set to 16/192 it plays the hi rez files the info on the track says 2/24/96 had to uninstall the soundmax software from ad to make it work THEN I was allowed to set rates etc in the sound devices:see attachments why i donīt get 24/192 in test I donīt know! best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on June 05, 2009, 11:06:36 pm Well Leif, this doesn't make much sense to me. So as I said, the file could be 16/96 (strange in the first place), but your DAC test shows in fact similar. Please note that XXHighend is able to play 24/96 files onto a 16/96 DAC, which seems just what you have been doing / setting now.
The first time that I see a "HD Audio device" properly working still has to come. But this one seems to beat all ! If you want you can still send me such a file, but as you said, it plays on Pedals system, so most probably the file is allright. However, I still wonder why XX tells you that the "384000" is not supported, while that is just the one which *is* supported (compare your earlier post with the DAC test and this number). So, I still think I do something wrong ... Nevertheless this all makes no sense to me. :sorry: Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 05, 2009, 11:45:01 pm true,but like a friend of mine, Gary Dews of Borderpatrol, says: if it sounds right,it probably is 8)
weīll figure it out , eventually! good night best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: pedal on June 06, 2009, 12:00:02 am BTW: The music files are downloaded/purchased from Blue Coast Records, a 24/96 sampler album with GREAT, GREAT sound. A mix of small scale blues with very good performers in the tradition of Muddy Waters/Folk Singer. The best SQ I have heard from this kind of music. Highly recomended!
The rest of the story, Leif will tell himself. (It's a story with a happy ending). Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 06, 2009, 12:06:36 am what are you doing on the web? shouldnīt you be B/&%&)& your wife by now ;)
best Leif"past 50" Christensen Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: pedal on June 06, 2009, 12:24:39 am what are you doing on the web? shouldnīt you be B/&%&)& your wife by now ;) best Leif"past 50" Christensen Hmmm. It's a hard choice between hi-rez and sex, but on second thoughts.......... Good night! :love: Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 06, 2009, 12:41:44 am traitor! :o
Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on June 06, 2009, 08:21:54 am BTW: The music files are downloaded/purchased from Blue Coast Records, a 24/96 sampler album with GREAT, GREAT sound. A mix of small scale blues with very good performers in the tradition of Muddy Waters/Folk Singer. The best SQ I have heard from this kind of music. Highly recomended! Ah, I wanted those myself anyway. Production "within 24 hours", so no time to compress. Haha. I will get them and let you know. Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 06, 2009, 03:59:41 pm they sound good,but AHHHHH soooo boring music,as often is the case with these audiophile releases
I couldnīt keep awake, so Iīm back to redbook Louis Armstrong @Dukeīs place :) who cares what format it is....it donīt mean a thing if it ainīt got that swing playing on the spdif output via 10m cables from basement musicserver to Buffalo 9008 and all is well :veryhappy: imo Best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: pedal on June 07, 2009, 12:49:54 am they sound good,but AHHHHH soooo boring music,as often is the case with these audiophile releases I disagree! It is true that "audiophile releases" with unknown artists often sounds boring, but this album is great musicianship. IF you happen to like simple rural blues. But, ok, let's be honest, I wouldn't spend $40 for this 12 track album, if it wasn't because of the 24/96 SQ :soundsgood:I truly enjoyed this album, and will play it again, from time to time. Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: leifchristensen on June 07, 2009, 12:55:36 am good musicians but their repotoire is downright boring
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ if I had to listing to only this kind of music I would rather change my hobby to knitting! IMO best Leif Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: komsansr on July 12, 2009, 06:51:55 am Hi
At 1st .. I never posted in any forum .. sorry if i made some wrong My system OS : Window 7 Sound card on board : Realtek HD Audio Device .. ALC833.. specification HD Audio Headphone : out 2X44.1-192kHz, 24bit HD Audio Speaker : out 8X44.1-192kHz, 24bit HD Audio SPDIF : out 2X44.1-192kHz, 32bit Playback Device from Control Panel : ..from advance tab..Max avialable bit and sample rate is 24bit@192kHz all Audio File : wav format both 16bit@44.1kHz and 24bit@96kHZ Audio Player : Foobar 2000 with WASAPI From system above, I could play all audio file I have With XXHighEnd, I could play all 16bit@44.1 file with #3 engine .. but couldnt for 24bit@96kHz file I tried to activate DAC test then. and for Output : Speaker Engine : #3 mode : DAC test Result Start Audio Device Analysis Exclusive Mode support Speakers (High Definition Audio Device) Supported : 2|16|44100|176400|4 Not supported : 2|24|44100|264600|6 Not supported : 2|32|44100|352800|8 Supported : 2|16|48000|192000|4 Not supported : 2|24|48000|288000|6 Not supported : 2|32|48000|384000|8 Not supported : 2|16|88200|352800|4 Not supported : 2|24|88200|529200|6 Not supported : 2|32|88200|705600|8 Supported : 2|16|96000|384000|4 Not supported : 2|24|96000|576000|6 Not supported : 2|32|96000|768000|8 Not supported : 2|16|176400|705600|4 Not supported : 2|24|176400|1058400|6 Not supported : 2|32|176400|1411200|8 Supported : 2|16|192000|768000|4 Not supported : 2|24|192000|1152000|6 Not supported : 2|32|192000|1536000|8 Not supported : 2|16|352800|1411200|4 Not supported : 2|24|352800|2116800|6 Not supported : 2|32|352800|2822400|8 Not supported : 2|16|384000|1536000|4 Not supported : 2|24|384000|2304000|6 Not supported : 2|32|384000|3072000|8 this may mean that i cant play my 24bit@96kHz file with this sound card. I tried to test again with DAC test share mode ... and I set bit and sample rate at 24bit@192kHz in playback device Exclusive Mode (with 16bit@44.1kHz file) Result Start Audio Device Analysis Shared Mode support Speakers (High Definition Audio Device) Supported : 2|16|44100|176400|4 Supported : 2|24|44100|264600|6 Supported : 2|32|44100|352800|8 Supported : 2|16|48000|192000|4 Supported : 2|24|48000|288000|6 Supported : 2|32|48000|384000|8 Supported : 2|16|88200|352800|4 Supported : 2|24|88200|529200|6 Supported : 2|32|88200|705600|8 Supported : 2|16|96000|384000|4 Supported : 2|24|96000|576000|6 Supported : 2|32|96000|768000|8 Supported : 2|16|176400|705600|4 Supported : 2|24|176400|1058400|6 Supported : 2|32|176400|1411200|8 Supported : 2|16|192000|768000|4 Not supported : 2|24|192000|1152000|6 Not supported : 2|32|192000|1536000|8 Supported : 2|16|352800|1411200|4 Supported : 2|24|352800|2116800|6 Supported : 2|32|352800|2822400|8 Supported : 2|16|384000|1536000|4 Supported : 2|24|384000|2304000|6 Supported : 2|32|384000|3072000|8 I tried to play my 24bit@96kHz then at dac is 24bit 96kHz.. the file edit from 16bit@44.1kHz by Wavelab 5.. error : Endpoint Create Failed > The DAC does not accept this byte sequence error : 2/32/96000/768000/8 error : Device cannot play error : engine #3 did not start within the expected time I tried to test again with DAC test share mode at 24bit@96kHz in playback device Exclusive Mode. Result Start Audio Device Analysis Shared Mode support Speakers (High Definition Audio Device) Supported : 2|16|44100|176400|4 Supported : 2|24|44100|264600|6 Supported : 2|32|44100|352800|8 Supported : 2|16|48000|192000|4 Supported : 2|24|48000|288000|6 Supported : 2|32|48000|384000|8 Supported : 2|16|88200|352800|4 Supported : 2|24|88200|529200|6 Supported : 2|32|88200|705600|8 Supported : 2|16|96000|384000|4 Not supported : 2|24|96000|576000|6 Not supported : 2|32|96000|768000|8 Supported : 2|16|176400|705600|4 Supported : 2|24|176400|1058400|6 Supported : 2|32|176400|1411200|8 Supported : 2|16|192000|768000|4 Supported : 2|24|192000|1152000|6 Supported : 2|32|192000|1536000|8 Supported : 2|16|352800|1411200|4 Supported : 2|24|352800|2116800|6 Supported : 2|32|352800|2822400|8 Supported : 2|16|384000|1536000|4 Supported : 2|24|384000|2304000|6 Supported : 2|32|384000|3072000|8 And I tried to play the same 24bit@96kHz file at dac is 24bit 192kHz.. error : Endpoint Create Failed > The DAC does not accept this byte sequence error : 2/32/96000/768000/8 error : Device cannot play End I have no more idea then and could not go further. If u ll have any comment .. plZ Sound quality of XXHighEnd s very nice and impressed me so much. Sorry for my english. It s not my native Thk komsansr Thailand Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on July 12, 2009, 09:13:06 am Well, let me tell you first that all looks the most thorough as can be, and you did/tried all very well. Hats off, also for your presented analysis !
(btw note the Shared Mode test is unofficial, and also unreliable, because although I stuffed it in for helping me a little in these kind of situations, it wasn't finished at the time (of this version)). I never saw combintations like this, and I do *not* blame W7 for it. Could be, but I don't think so. It merely will be the audio device containing properties I do not anticipate upon sufficiently. Now, I know already that all these "HD Audio" devices can't be dealt with properly, and although this will be part of the base problem, this is just a new one I never saw before. Coincidentally right now I am working on similar problems for a few days already (not specifically hi-rez related), and I guess I only quit that when I solved it. So far I don't see the solutions (read : I can't see what is wrong, but it still does not work), and exactly like in your case - in Foobar it works. The audio device not working I have at hand here, as I have at hand PCs with the HD Audio devices causing problems (as said, not the same HD Audio as yours). I guess when I found what's wrong with that, I will have solved your problem too. It is the only thing to do anyway, because I don't have such a device here. I will let you know when I have some results, ok ? Regards, Peter Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on July 12, 2009, 11:14:10 am Allright, per pure coincidence of the timing of your post, this just have been solved (well, I said I was working on it :)).
The coincidence is merely about the fact that this problem has been there right from the beginning, and now at last I found the culprit. Please keep in mind : whether it works for your device just the same has to be awaitened, but I'm confident it will. It will be in the next version (0.9y), which is hopefully there within two weeks. Peter Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: SeVeReD on July 13, 2009, 04:39:02 am Allright, per pure coincidence of the timing of your post, this just have been solved (well, I said I was working on it :)). The coincidence is merely about the fact that this problem has been there right from the beginning, and now at last I found the culprit. Please keep in mind : whether it works for your device just the same has to be awaitened, but I'm confident it will. It will be in the next version (0.9y), which is hopefully there within two weeks. Peter Does this mean you think you've got empirical and benchmark dac things working? That would be a nice buggerboo to solve. gl Title: Re: will not play hi-rez files Post by: PeterSt on July 13, 2009, 05:47:50 am Yes ... although the Benchmark must be tested by someone first, in order to be sure.
|